Jan 30, 2023
Bans on Toxic Gas Stoves Ignore the Root Cause of Indoor Pollution
Gas cooking is toxic, but so is ALL cooking without ventilation. Homeowners don't have a clue.
By: Matt Power
Recent studies have “discovered” that cooking with gas stoves in your home has a direct link to childhood asthma and other terrible health side effects. But what’s not discussed in the media coverage is the fact that in most homes, use of proper ventilation is sorely lacking. All forms of cooking indoors release toxins into the home, including electric cooktops. Gas appliances simply add a few noxious fumes to the mix.
While I’m in agreement that gas stoves need to be phased out in homes, in favor of electric tops that can be powered with renewable energy sources, the reason to do this now is the Climate Crisis, not asthma. Why? Because Climate Change is an existential threat, whereas indoor air quality can be managed mechanically. If you already own a gas range, and are panicked by the prognosis of doom offered by new research, take a breath, and start using your range hood. You may be able to live safely in your home until the gas company goes bankrupt in a few years.
I’ve written about this topic for several years now. Misinformation is part of the problem. User resistance is the other. For example, many people believe (wrongly) that the recirculating range hoods common on microwaves are enough to clear cooking toxins. That’s far from the truth. In fact, after their initial use, most of these catch less than 20 percent of particulates. Range hoods need to take dirty air and smoke outdoors. And they need a place to “pull” in fresh air from outside.
In my many years covering hundreds of new homes and renovations, I’d say that most newer homes have range hoods installed that are almost never used, even when their kids unexplainedly develop asthma. They simply don’t believe cooking and poor health could be connected.
Why Homeowners Don’t Use Range Hoods
As part of a study of kitchen usage, the Center for Real Life Kitchen Design at Virginia Tech asked many questions about when and how people use kitchen range hoods. The big three: noise, ignorance, and belief that it’s “not necessary.” Here’s an excerpt:
“The participants in the interview cooked on a regular and frequent basis: 68 percent cooked complete meals five or more times per week and 97 percent prepared dinner on a regular basis. Common cooking activities that were done on a regular basis included: baking (83 percent), stir frying (56 percent), quantity freezing (36 percent), preparing gourmet foods (32 percent), and canning (32 percent).
The majority of participants (84 percent) had electric ranges. Most of the participants (92 percent) owned a microwave oven. An interesting finding is that 32 percent used the microwave oven about the same as their range top, and 31 percent used the microwave oven more than the range top.
Most of the participants (92 percent) reported having mechanical kitchen ventilation systems. The most common type of kitchen ventilation system was an updraft system — hood attached to a cabinet over the cook top or range.
The most common features in the ventilation systems were a light (91 percent) and a multi-speed fan (84 percent). The majority of the ventilation systems (55 percent) were ducted to the outside. However, 17 percent of the participants did not know if their ventilation systems exhausted to the outside.”
Here’s the REALLY interesting part: “Only 8 percent of the participants used their ventilation system whenever they cooked, while 8 percent used ventilation “almost never,” and 15 percent used ventilation only “once in a while.”
Controlling odors and smoke were the most common reasons for using a kitchen ventilation system. Noise was the most common reason for avoiding the kitchen ventilation system. Table 4 describes the most frequent reasons that people cited for using or not using their kitchen ventilation systems.
Participants gave various reasons for using their kitchen ventilation systems specifically with cook top cooking, typically to solve problems with odor, smoke, and steam. Kitchen ventilation was less common when only the oven was being used. When using the oven, 46 percent never used ventilation, while 28 percent only used ventilation for oily/greasy foods and 17 percent for smelly foods.”
The Gas Must Go, But Make Ventilation Mandatory Now
As you see, pointing the finger at natural gas as a silent indoor health threat is looking at just one murky slice of a much larger pie. What’s needed immediately is close attention to ventilation and fresh air uptake.
One way to achieve this is to make range hood technology automatic. Take user resistance right out of the equation. This could be written right into the building code, and could be achieved as a retrofit at minimal cost.
One of the best innovations in range hood technology in recent years have been particle- and heat-sensing devices. In our view, these devices should become the de facto standard across the industry. Further, it’s time for range hoods to be integrated with the Internet of Things. For homeowners, reluctant or not, there would be clear health benefits to regular use of range hoods. And for those who choose not to use the hoods, landlords, devices that are “smart” can automatically kick on anyways, clearing the air for everyone else who lives in the building.
This blog post originally appeared on the Green Builder website and is reprinted with permission.